Compare · iPad or Windows for Zone 1

Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC vs Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch

These two tablets do different jobs, so this is a choice between Windows and iPadOS for Zone 1 work. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is a 10.1-inch intrinsically safe (Ex ia) tablet that runs x86 Windows 11 IoT Enterprise and is Zone 0 rated inside its supplied case. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is a flameproof (Ex db) cover around an iPad Pro 11-inch (M5), rated T6 for Zone 1/21 under ATEX, with LiDAR and a 1,000-nit screen. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is T4 but holds IECEx, a North American listing and a +55 °C rating, where the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is ATEX only and rated to +45 °C. Here is how they compare, and which we would choose for which team.

Our verdict

Which should you choose?

Pick by the software your team has to run and the gases on your site. If your Zone 1 work needs desktop Windows software, Zone 0 access or a North American listing, we would choose the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC. If you run iPad apps, work with gases that ignite below 135 °C, or want photos, LiDAR scans and a brighter screen in Zone 1/21 under ATEX, we would choose the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch.

Choose the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC if…

  • Your engineers or inspectors run desktop Windows software in Zone 1: it is an x86 tablet with Windows 11 IoT Enterprise, and an iPad cannot run Windows applications.
  • Some of your work is in Zone 0: it is rated Ga/Da for it inside the case Eaton supplies, while the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is certified for Zone 1/21 only.
  • Your sites need IECEx or a North American listing: it holds IECEx NMK 25.0029X and a Class I Division 1 listing for Groups C and D, while the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is ATEX only, with IECEx planned.
  • Your sites run hot: it is certified up to +55 °C ambient, against +45 °C for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch.
  • Your site bans cameras: Eaton offers a camera-free version, and our data lists none for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch.
Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC in full

Choose the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch if…

  • Your hazardous-area study includes gases that ignite below 135 °C: it is rated T6 (85 °C) and T80 °C for dust, against T4 and 135 °C for the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC.
  • Your inspectors take photos, video and 3D scans: the 12 MP camera with 4K ProRes video and the LiDAR scanner work through the cover, against 8 MP and 1080p video, with no depth sensor, on the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC.
  • You want a brighter screen on a lighter tablet: up to 1,000 nits against 540 nits, and 1,350 g including the iPad against 1,430 g.
  • You already manage iPads: it is a standard iPad Pro 11-inch (M5) inside, with the same apps and Apple device management, 12 or 16 GB of memory and Wi-Fi 7.
Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch in full

Key differences

Where they differ

  • Windows software

    Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC
    Built in (Windows 11 IoT, x86)
    Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
    Not possible (iPadOS only)

    The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC runs x86 Windows software natively. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch runs iPadOS only, so Windows applications do not run on it. If your software exists only for Windows, the choice is made.

  • Zone 0 or Zone 1 only

    Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC
    Ga / Da
    Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
    Gb / Db

    The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is rated Ga/Da, and Eaton limits Zone 0 use to the case it supplies. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is rated Gb/Db for Zone 1/21. If any of your work is in Zone 0, only the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC qualifies, and only inside that case.

  • Temperature class

    Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC
    T4 (≤ 135 °C)
    Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
    T6 (≤ 85 °C)

    T6 keeps the surface at or below 85 °C and T4 at or below 135 °C. T4 is fine for most gases but not those that ignite below 135 °C, so check the ignition temperatures of your substances against the class.

  • Maximum ambient temperature

    Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC
    −20 °C to +55 °C
    Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
    −20 °C to +45 °C

    The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC has 10 °C more headroom than the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch, which matters for plants and yards in hot climates. Go by the ambient range in the certificate, not the operating range on a datasheet.

  • LiDAR and 3D scanning

    Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC
    Not possible (no depth sensor)
    Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
    Built in (iPad Pro LiDAR); Xshielder lists 'Pro camera with LiDAR'

    The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch has the iPad Pro’s LiDAR scanner, and Xshielder confirms it works through the cover. Our data lists no depth sensor for the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC.

In the field

Head to head, by kind of work

Windows software, platform and updates

Edge: Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC

This is the real dividing line. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC runs Windows 11 IoT Enterprise on an Intel quad-core Atom (Apollo Lake) at 1.6 GHz, with 8 GB of RAM, 256 GB of storage and a microSDXC slot up to 2 TB, and our data lists Windows desktop software as built in. For teams whose plant, maintenance or engineering software exists only as a Windows application, that is the whole case for it.

The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch runs iPadOS 27 on an Apple M5 with 12 or 16 GB of memory and 256 GB to 2 TB of storage, with the same apps and Apple device management as any iPad. On updates, our data gives October 2034 for the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC, but that is Microsoft’s date for the Windows 11 IoT Enterprise LTSC 2024 edition and Eaton does not state which edition it ships. Xshielder expects 7–8 years, based on previous iPad Pro support. We would not choose on either date.

Gas coverage and temperature class

Edge: Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch

Both tablets are certified for gas group IIC and dust group IIIC under ATEX, but the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is rated T6, with a maximum surface temperature of 85 °C for gas and 80 °C for dust. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is T4, with 135 °C for both. T4 is fine for most gases, but not those that ignite below 135 °C. If your hazardous-area study lists none, the gap will not matter to you.

The protection methods differ too. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is intrinsically safe (Ex ia), which limits the energy in the device. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is a flameproof (Ex db) cover that contains an explosion instead. Under the North American listing the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC’s gas group is IIB, covering Class I Division 1 Groups C and D, so hydrogen and acetylene (Groups B and A) are outside that listing.

Zone 0, approvals and heat

Edge: Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC

The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC has the wider range of places it may be used. It is rated Ga/Da, with the ATEX marking II 1GD, and Eaton limits Zone 0 use to the case it supplies, with a friction hazard noted in the conditions of use. Outside Zone 0 it holds ATEX (Nemko 25ATEX1018X) and IECEx (NMK 25.0029X) certificates and a UL listing, which also lists it for Class I Zone 0 AEx ia IIB T4. Xshielder confirms ATEX certification for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch, has published no certificate number yet, and plans IECEx. Our data has no North American listing for it.

Heat is the other gap. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is certified from −20 °C to +55 °C, against −20 °C to +45 °C for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch. In the zone, Eaton allows no accessories or extensions on its tablet, and its SIM and microSD slots must stay closed. Eaton’s conditions say to charge it only with its own charger, outside the hazardous area.

Screen, cameras, battery and carrying

Even

The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch has the brighter screen and the better cameras. Its 11-inch Ultra Retina XDR display reaches 1,000 nits (SDR maximum) at 2420 × 1668, against 540 nits at 2560 × 1600 on the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC’s 10.1-inch panel. Xshielder confirms that the 12 MP rear camera with 4K video and ProRes, the LiDAR scanner and the Face ID front camera work through the cover. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC has an 8 MP autofocus camera with 1080p video, and a camera-free version for sites that ban cameras.

The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC has the bigger battery, 49.68 Wh against 31.29 Wh, and Eaton quotes a typical 12 hours; our data lists up to 10 hours of web or video on Wi-Fi for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch. These are makers’ figures measured in different ways, so test your own workload. Neither battery is user-replaceable. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch weighs 1,350 g including the iPad, 80 g less than the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC at 1,430 g. Eaton’s IP67 comes from the ATEX marking in its manual, not the IECEx certificate, and the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch’s IP65 is pending testing. We call this section even.

Specifications

Full specifications side by side

Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC vs Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: full specifications
Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PCXshielder iPad Pro 11-inch
Ex rating
Certified forZone 1/21Zone 1/21
ProtectionIntrinsic safety (Ex ia)Flameproof enclosure (Ex db)
Gas groupIICIIC
Temperature classT4 (≤ 135 °C)T6 (≤ 85 °C)
Certification
ATEX markingII 1GD Ex ia IIC T4 Ga / II 1GD Ex ia IIIC T135°C DaII 2G Ex db IIC T6 Gb / II 2D Ex tb IIIC T80°C Db
ATEX certificateNemko 25ATEX1018XATEX certified
IECEx markingEx ia IIC T4 Ga / Ex ia IIIC T135°C DaNot in our data
IECEx certificateIECEx NMK 25.0029X (Issue 0, 2026-05-26)Not in our data
Other approvalsUL 913 / CSA C22.2 No. 60079-0 and -11Lanyard hole to NS-9611 (pending testing)
North AmericaUL certificate CER230869: Class I Div 1 Groups C, D T4; Class I Zone 0 AEx ia IIB T4 Ga (US) / Ex ia IIB T4 Ga (CAN); UL 913 8th ed. Class I, II, III Div 1. Gas group is IIB in North America, IIC in Europe/IECEx.Not in our data
Zone 0Zone 0 rated only inside the case supplied by the maker.Not in our data
Protection level (EPL)Ga / DaGb / Db
Dust groupIIICIIIC
Max surface temperature (dust)135 °C80 °C
Safe use
Ambient temperature (Ta)−20 °C to +55 °C−20 °C to +45 °C
ChargingOutside the hazardous area onlyNot in our data
Battery swapOutside the hazardous area onlyOutside the hazardous area only
Ports and accessories in the zoneNo accessories or extensions in the hazardous area; SIM/microSD slots not to be opened; docking connector and charging only in safe areas.Not in our data
Certified accessoriesEaton accessory list: carry case GEC-ATP-CC-01 (required in Zone 0), anti-glare screen protector GEC-ATP-AGSP-01, USB cables GEC-ATP-STUSBS-01, IS USB adapter GEC-ATP-ISUSB-01, shoulder strap GEC-ATP-SHST-01, stylus with tether GEC-ATP-STYT-01, docking station GEC-ATP-DOST-01 (safe area), hands-free harness GEC-ATP-HFHA-01, power adapter GEC-ATP-POAD-XX-01. Ex-area use of each accessory is not stated beyond the case, strap and stylus.Xshielder Stylus (capacitive, 22 g, aluminium, with lanyard). Ex rating of the stylus not stated. Apple Pencil not mentioned.Unconfirmed, see note 1
IP code in the Ex certificateIP67 in the ATEX marking printed in Eaton's manual (Nemko 25ATEX1018X ... Um = 20V IP67); not in the IECEx database marking for NMK 25.0029XUnconfirmed, see note 2Not in our data
Operating temperature−20 °C to +55 °C−20 °C to +45 °CUnconfirmed, see note 3
Conditions of useDo not remove or replace the battery pack in hazardous areas; use only battery AAEB-100-XX and charge it only on the tablet; charge only with Eaton charger GEC-ATP-POAD-x-01; do not open the SIM/SD port in a hazardous location; in Zone 0 use only inside Eaton case GEC-ATP-CC-01 (friction hazard); avoid friction on the enclosure; inspect for damage; service only by Eaton; do not charge, connect or disconnect in hazardous areas; no accessories or extensions in hazardous areas (IECEx NMK 25.0029X conditions a-j). Um = 20 V appears in the ATEX/UL marking printed in the instruction manual, not in the IECEx text.Not in our data
Device
TypeDedicated Ex tabletCertified Ex case
Tablet insideNot in our dataiPad Pro 11-inch (M5)
Also fitsNot in our dataiPad Pro 11-inch (M4)
FittingNot in our dataFitted by the makerUnconfirmed, see note 4
Tablet can be removedNot in our dataYes, but only by Xshielder authorised personnel (lid glued on the ATEX version)Unconfirmed, see note 4
Launched2026Unconfirmed, see note 52026
Part numbersGZ1A1W51A1A1 (WiFi); GZ1A1G51A1A1 (LTE); carry case GEC-ATP-CC-01; dock GEC-ATP-DOST-01XS1-TB-G01-C01-S01; datasheet ref. iPad11P-000033-1
Operating systemWindows 11 IoT EnterpriseiPadOS 27
EditionWindows 11 IoT Enterprise (channel/LTSC year not stated; Eaton: 'Windows 11 IoT')Unconfirmed, see note 6iPadOS (consumer; no LTSC or enterprise edition)
OS at launchNot in our dataiPadOS 26
OS upgradesNot in our dataStill supported by iPadOS 27 (current)
Security updatesUntil October 2034Unconfirmed, see note 77–8 years (based on previous iPad Pro support)
ProcessorIntel quad-core Atom (Apollo Lake) 1.6 GHz base, 1.8 GHz burstApple M5 (up to 10-core CPU)
Processor architecturex86Arm
Memory (RAM)8 GB12 (256/512 GB) / 16 (1/2 TB)
Storage256 GB, MicroSDXC up to 2 TB256 GB, 512 GB, 1024 GB, 2048 GB
What works through the housing or case
Face ID / Touch IDNot in our dataYes: Face ID works through the cover (confirmed by Xshielder)
Apple Pencil / stylusNot in our dataYes: stylus input works through the cover (confirmed by Xshielder); Xshielder capacitive stylus (22 g, interchangeable tips, lanyard) offered
Side and volume buttonsNot in our dataYes: usable through the cover (Xshielder: all iPad Pro functions available)
Rear camerasNot in our dataYes: 12 MP Wide camera with 4K video and ProRes works through the cover (confirmed by Xshielder)
LiDARNot in our dataYes: LiDAR works through the cover (confirmed by Xshielder)
Front cameraNot in our dataYes: landscape 12 MP Center Stage camera with Face ID works through the cover (confirmed by Xshielder)
TouchscreenNot in our dataYes: works through the cover (Xshielder: all iPad Pro functions available)
ChargingNot in our dataUSB-C charging as on a standard iPad Pro (confirmed by Xshielder); 50% in 30 min with a 60 W adapter (M5); no wireless
Speakers and microphonesNot in our dataYes: all 4 microphones and 4 speakers usable (confirmed by Xshielder)
Headset audioNot in our dataYes: audio in and out works (confirmed by Xshielder); headsets via USB-C or Bluetooth, as the iPad Pro has no 3.5 mm jack
USB-C portNot in our dataYes: accessible for charging and data, as on a standard iPad Pro (confirmed by Xshielder)
SIM cardNot in our dataeSIM only (1 x eSIM, cellular models); no SIM tray
Removed or disabledNot in our dataNothing removed or disabled: all iPad Pro features available (confirmed by Xshielder)
Mounting pointsNot in our data1/4-inch tripod mount; lanyard hole to NS-9611 (pending testing)
Field capabilities
Push-to-talkNot in our dataVia app (third-party PTT apps over Wi-Fi/cellular; no PTT key; Ex-rated? n/a)
Lone workerNot in our dataVia app (third-party lone-worker apps)
Barcode scanningVia app (camera-based; Eaton lists no scan engine)Via app (camera-based scanning; no scan engine)
NFC readingBuilt in (NFC)Not possible (no NFC reader on any iPad)Unconfirmed, see note 8
3D scanning / LiDARNot possible (no depth sensor)Built in (iPad Pro LiDAR); Xshielder lists 'Pro camera with LiDAR'
Remote expert / video callsVia app (front and rear cameras; a camera-free version is also offered)Via app (FaceTime, Teams or remote-assist apps; cameras and audio work through the cover)
Windows desktop softwareBuilt in (Windows 11 IoT, x86)Not possible (iPadOS only)
Bluetooth gas detectorsNot in our dataVia app (Bluetooth 6 (M5) / 5.3 (M4); vendor app; no maker-certified integration listed)
Display and camera
Display10.1-inch AHVA (IPS-type), 1000:1 contrast, 170 degree viewing angle11-inch Ultra Retina XDR tandem OLED, ProMotion 10-120 Hz, P3, True Tone, antireflective coating; nano-texture glass option on 1 and 2 TB
Resolution2560 × 1600 (WQXGA)2420 × 1668 (264 ppi)
Brightness540 nits1000 (SDR max)
Pen / stylusStylus supplied (type not stated)Apple Pencil Pro, Apple Pencil (USB-C); magnetic attach and charge, hover
Rear camera8 MP autofocus with flash (Eaton: camera-free version available)12 MP Wide, f/1.8, True Tone flash
Front cameraFront camera 1920 x 1080 stills (megapixels not stated; 2 MP in Eaton manual)12 MP Center Stage, landscape, TrueDepth (Face ID)
Video1080p at 30 fps4K video, ProRes
Depth sensingNot in our dataLiDAR scanner
Connectivity
NetworkWi-Fi; optional LTE-A Cat 12 / UMTSWi-Fi only or Wi-Fi + Cellular (5G sub-6 GHz)
Wi-Fi802.11 a/b/g/n/acWi-Fi 7 (802.11be), 2x2 MIMO
BluetoothBluetooth 5.2Bluetooth 6
NFCYesNot in our data
Satellite positioningGPS, GLONASS, GalileoGPS/GNSS on Wi-Fi + Cellular models; digital compass and Wi-Fi location on all
SIMNano-SIM (LTE version)eSIM only (cellular models)
Physical and power
Weight1430 g1350 g (including the tablet)
Dimensions278 × 207 × 13.8 (28.3 at battery section) mm289 × 217 × 16 mm
Ingress protectionIP67IP65 (pending testing)Unconfirmed, see note 9
Battery2 x 3450 (7.2 V)8160Unconfirmed, see note 10
Battery energy49.6831.29
Battery lifeTypical 12 h (Eaton datasheet)Up to 10 hours web or video on Wi-Fi
Hot-swap batteryNot in our dataNo
Replaceable batteryNoNo
Ports and expansion5-pin magnetic charging connector; docking connector (LAN, USB 2.0/3.0, USB-C, HDMI, SD, audio jack); microSDXC and nano-SIM under port cover; VESA 75 x 35 mm mount (Eaton)Thunderbolt / USB 4 (USB-C, up to 40 Gb/s); Smart Connector; magnetic Apple Pencil connector
DockingDock DS100M (Aegex) / GEC-ATP-DOST-01 (Eaton), safe area only; shoulder strap; VESA mountUSB-C hubs and docks; Smart Connector or magnetic keyboard accessories where the iPad has them. Not usable through sealed Ex cases except the USB-C or Lightning charging port where the case exposes it.
KeyboardNo (slate)Smart Connector (Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro)
Controls & Accessibility
KeysNot in our dataTop button (no Touch ID; Face ID model), volume buttons; no programmable hardware key
Push-to-talk keyNot in our dataNo
BiometricsNot in our dataFace ID
Fleet and support
Preinstalled appsAegexScan barcode-scanning application (optional, Aegex)Not in our data
ManufacturerEaton Electric Limited (MTL), United KingdomXshielder AS, Norway

Only values we could check are listed; “Not in our data” means we have not verified it, not that the tablet lacks it. A numbered marker means a value is unconfirmed, and the matching note at the foot of the page explains why. Prices are on request for both.

Xshielder

Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch cover for Zone 1/21

A flameproof cover for the iPad Pro 11-inch (M5), certified IIC T6 for Zone 1/21 under ATEX, with the cameras, LiDAR and stylus input working through the cover. Tell us about your site and fleet size to get a quote. See the iPad Pro 11-inch cover.

FAQ

Common questions

Is the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC better than the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch?

Neither is better across the board, and they do different jobs. The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC suits teams that need x86 Windows software, Zone 0 access, a North American listing or +55 °C. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch suits teams that run iPad apps, handle gases that need T6, or want its screen, cameras and LiDAR. Both are certified for Zone 1/21.

Can either tablet be used in Zone 0?

Only the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC, and only inside the case supplied by Eaton. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is certified for Zone 1/21 (protection level Gb/Db) and is not certified for Zone 0.

Is either tablet approved for North America or IECEx?

The Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC is both: it holds IECEx NMK 25.0029X and a UL listing for Class I Division 1 Groups C and D at T4, so not Groups A or B. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch is ATEX only. IECEx is planned, and our data has no North American listing for it.

Which gets security updates for longer?

We cannot call it. Our data gives October 2034 for the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC, but that is Microsoft’s date for the Windows 11 IoT Enterprise LTSC 2024 edition, and Eaton does not state its edition. Xshielder expects 7–8 years for the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch, based on previous iPad Pro support. Ask each maker for the exact date for the version you order.

Can you charge either tablet in the hazardous area?

Not the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC: Eaton says it must be charged outside the hazardous area, and its battery is not user-replaceable. For the Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch our data has no value for charging inside the zone, so it is not confirmed either way. Its battery swap is outside the hazardous area only.

Can either tablet run Windows desktop software?

Only the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC, which runs x86 Windows 11 IoT Enterprise. The Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch runs iPadOS, so Windows applications do not run on it, though it runs iPad apps and works with Apple device management.

How much do the Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC and Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch cost?

Prices depend on volume, configuration and region, so both are on request. Contact us for a price.

Notes on unconfirmed values

  1. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: Not checked against the certificate for this exact model.
  2. Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC: From Eaton's manual; the IECEx certificate doesn't state an IP code.
  3. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: From a single source.
  4. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: Not stated by the maker for this exact model.
  5. Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC: Approximate: the maker doesn't publish a launch date. Based on the certificate date or the maker's announcement.
  6. Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC: The maker doesn't state the edition year.
  7. Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC: Microsoft's end date for Windows 11 IoT Enterprise LTSC 2024. The maker doesn't state the edition year.
  8. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: Not confirmed by the maker for this exact model.
  9. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: From a single source; not stated in the Ex certificate.
  10. Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch: Apple states battery capacity in watt-hours only; this figure is from the case maker's documents.

Facts last verified on against certificates, declarations of conformity and manufacturer data. The sources for each tablet are listed on its page: Eaton MTL GECMA IS Tablet PC and Xshielder iPad Pro 11-inch. Always check the certificate for your exact model before use. Spotted an error? Tell us.